RATE THE REF - Bobby Madley v Sunderland

[jdrobbo]

Bobby Madley (Ossett) v Sunderland

How to Score
A. Decision Making (including use of advantage) - out of 25
B. Consistency - out of 25
C. Fitness and Positioning - of 25
D. Control and Authority - out of 25

[ClaretTony]

A 18
B 18
C 20
D 18

[Vegas Claret]

A:20
B:20
C:20
D:22

I thought he was excellent today, didn't take crap from the home team, got all the big decisions right

[PaintYorkClaretnBlue]

Good game.

[minnieclaret]

Much better than posts 2 & 3 would suggest.

[CleggHall]

OK but could have booked a few more Sunderland players in the 2nd half.
Should we have had a penalty?
Missed the elbow on Ben Mee 1st half as did the lino who was 10 metres away.

[Ashingtonclaret46]

I was sat right opposite Janusaj's elbow on Ben Mee along with some Sunderland supporters who all thought that he was a very lucky guy to stay on the field. The general concensus amongst us was that it was deliberate -- only he knows!

[beddie]

Did okay, he dropped a bollock when trying to play advantage when Ben was assaulted in the first half, then failed to stop the game when Sunderland gained possession back, outside their box. There should have been several more bookings for Sunderland.

[ClaretTony]

Much better than posts 2 & 3 would suggest.

Is that a serious comment from someone who was or wasn't at the game?

[minnieclaret]

Is that a serious comment from someone who was or wasn't at the game?

I did watch it live and saw close ups of the contentious decisions, not your view from 100 yds away. He got them all right.
I've posted elsewhere the only thing he got wrong for me was not booking Jones for his studs up lunge, although very little if any contact was made.
Januzajs elbow was not deliberate. He made his leap and had his arm up before Ben ran into it.

[CaptJohn]

Decent game
A. 20
B. 20
C. 20
D. 20

[Wilsdenclaret]

22
22
22
24