RATE THE REF - Jon Moss v Manchester United

[jdrobbo]

Jon Moss (West Yorkshire) v Manchester United

How to Score
A. Decision Making (including use of advantage) - out of 25
B. Consistency - out of 25
C. Fitness and Positioning - of 25
D. Control and Authority - out of 25

[jdrobbo]

A 24
B 25
C 22
D 24

[MDWat]

A - 15
B - 15
C - 15
D - 20

Slightly better than average. Gave Wood nothing.

[cricketfieldclarets]

A. 25
B. 25
C. 18
D. 25

Thought he was absolutely superb. Despite giving them a penalty. He didnt have any big club bias and wasnt afraid to give the red right in front of their fans. Was just a good ref. No problems.

[joey13]

I preferred him on the drums

[MACCA]

20
23
23
23

Got a couple of big decisions wrong, thought United could have had another pen, missed the Mee handball, and didn't clamp down on the time wasting, but b8g sides rarely do.
Decent game though for us.

[Beagleheart]

20
21
18
22

[bobinho]

Not a bad ref, but.... not great either.

The Mee handball was obvious even to the light aeroplane pilot. Shocking decision to ignore it. Foul on Lukaku earlier by Mee not punished either. Timewasting not dealt with. Failed to give Wood ANYTHING. Had Barnes been playing, we would've had more free kicks. Wood not clever enough in that department-not the refs fault I grant you.

[Goodclaret]

Pretty much agree with Bobinho. Just because we were on the right side of Moss's decisions doesn't make him a good ref. Mee could/should have been sent off (twice?!). Bardsley was lucky with the kick out leading to Rashfords red. I thought the penalty was soft, not a chance we would have got that the other end. Let Utd time waste from about 55 minutes onwards. Fell for Pogba's "falls" more than once.

Nah, just not a good ref for me.

[DAVETHEVICAR]

A 18
B18
C 20
D 20

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

[Goodclaret]

A 18
B18
C 20
D 20

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

Actually hadn't realised he'd already been booked? I saw Moss go for his card then seemed to change his mind. If Pogba was on a yellow that would explain it. If so, another poor decision from Moss.

[taio]

Don't think Pogba was already on a yellow

[bfcjg]

Good ref.
A 20
B 19
C 22
D 21

[Carport]

A 18
B18
C 20
D 20

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

I was disgusted at Moss for that. He clearly went to his pocket for a card when Pogba deliberately handled and must have realised that he’d already booked him and therefore changed his mind. Rubbish.

[Vino blanco]

No probs with ref today, not great but didn't affect the result in any way.

[Granny WeatherWax]

A 18
B18
C 20
D 20

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

He hadn’t been booked

[Wokingclaret]

Cost us the 1st goal, fool on Wood
Miles off the pace

15
15
5
15

[CaptJohn]

15 Couldn't wait to point to the spot for them.
15 Sorry Mr Moss you favoured them.
20 No issues
20 Was in control of Burnley.

[ALP]

A 23
B 23
C 22
D 24

[nil_desperandum]

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

Should have been a yellow for the handball, but can't think of any other previous incident where Pogba might have got a yellow, and the stats say he didn't.

[Wilsdenclaret]

I preferred him on the drums

Boy George prefered him on his trumpet

[Juan Tanamera]

A 18
B18
C 20
D 20

Is there only me who thought Pogba should have had a second yellow for deliberate handball
He gave us the free kick

Most fans around me noted that Moss was reaching into his pocket then changed his mind.
Sending 2 Manyoo players off in the same game is a no-no and to be fair, Ben Mee could just have easily been sent off for that 'handball'

[Giftonsnoidea]

The camera caught pogba demonstrating with him and he smiled and changed his mind on booking him! referee the game properly you dumbo! Give a card where it is due and don’t be swayed because they play for a big club!

The ref against olympiacos was superb, he should watch a video of him.

From being an appalling ref a few years ago he has certainly improved and had to now the best chap we had is in Saudi Arabia.

[IanMcL]

Surprisingly high marks. Thought he was too far from a lot if things and gave a really soft penalty, which we would never have got.

I have seen worse.

[Woodleyclaret]

Super Jonny Moss is the worst ref of a poor bunch.United commited a string of fouls and Pogba should have gone for deliberate handball.
Moss is great working the subs board anything else is a step too far

[ClaretTony]

A. 22
B. 20
C. 17
D. 20