Referee confirmed for Everton game

[ClaretTony]

Graham Scott

http://www.uptheclarets.com/referee-con ... ton-game-6" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

[Barry_Chuckle]

Beam me up......

[IanMcL]

He is below biased Mason, in the table.

[jdrobbo]

[CharlieinNewMexico]

Literally tries his best to be anonymous. Won't give anything either way.

[Longside4evr]

Happy with this theirs a lot worse than Scott.
But ref's shouldn't matter now we have VAR
We have had two goals ruled out that would have definitely been given but for VAR
away at Arsenal and at Villa now so its helped us to a degree
The only time it might have gone for us is at Wolverhampton but VAR went with the Ref soft all be it but you couldn't argue

[scouseclaret]

Happy with this theirs a lot worse than Scott.
But ref's shouldn't matter now we have VAR
We have had two goals ruled out that would have definitely been given but for VAR
away at Arsenal and at Villa now so its helped us to a degree
The only time it might have gone for us is at Wolverhampton but VAR went with the Ref soft all be it but you couldn't argue

Should definitely had a pen v Norwich as well, but refs seem to have decided amongst themselves not to overturn penalty decisions.

[Longside4evr]

We should have against Norwich and this is one reason I think that each team should be allowed 2 appeals per game
Thankfully the Norwich decision didn't alter the points tally

[clitheroeclaret2]

We should have against Norwich and this is one reason I think that each team should be allowed 2 appeals per game
Thankfully the Norwich decision didn't alter the points tally

Exactly, similar as in tennis and cricket where the system works very well

[Woodleyclaret]

Better than Super Jonny Moss and Useless Mason
But then all three are pretty weak.

[Rileybobs]

We should have against Norwich and this is one reason I think that each team should be allowed 2 appeals per game
Thankfully the Norwich decision didn't alter the points tally

But they reviewed the challenge on Barnes and decided to stick with the referee's decision - so the appeal wouldn't have made a difference.

The idea of teams having appeals is daft, they would be used every time a team conceded a goal on the off-chance that there was an offside or innocuous infringement in the build up to the goal.

[CharlieinNewMexico]

Moss, Mason, Scott, East.

The relegation candidates.
Pawson sinking fast desperate for a point.

Coote, Kavanagh showing them how it's done.

[Longside4evr]

But they reviewed the challenge on Barnes and decided to stick with the referee's decision - so the appeal wouldn't have made a difference.

The idea of teams having appeals is daft, they would be used every time a team conceded a goal on the off-chance that there was an offside or innocuous infringement in the build up to the goal.

That's why I propose 2 decisions it works in all other sport tennis rugby cricket
Its all to early to make daft assumptions

Not sure the penalty decision against Barnes went to VAR the ref just played on
But players are professionals and I dont think you would get teams just willy nilly using an appeal on cheap question of asking

[Rileybobs]

That's why I propose 2 decisions it works in all other sport tennis rugby cricket
Its all to early to make daft assumptions

Not sure the penalty decision against Barnes went to VAR the ref just played on
But players are professionals and I dont think you would get teams just willy nilly using an appeal on cheap question of asking

A goal is such a match-changing and infrequent event that every goal would be challenged. What bigger decisions would the challenges be saved for?

Wickets in cricket and points in tennis don’t even come close to comparison, but in both of those sports you still see frivolous appeals at times such as key wickets or game/set points.

[Longside4evr]

Ok it's only an idea in case the team defending a incident that the officials missed
Like off the ball incidents linner giving a corner or free kick or a throw in that leads to a goal
Things like this happen all the time
Dyche could flag it up and appeal players play acting that hes banged on about to cause a booking
Like hes mentioned before they get away with the first a yellow
This could be flag up for blatant cheating straight red in my book