Penalty?
-
- Posts: 16844
- Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2016 4:37 pm
- Been Liked: 6950 times
- Has Liked: 1479 times
- Location: Leeds
Re: Penalty?
Surprised nobody has asked this.
These 8 users liked this post: fidelcastro gawthorpe_view FactualFrank dpinsussex Ashingtonclaret46 Bigvince Dark Cloud simonclaret
-
- Posts: 7210
- Joined: Sun Jan 17, 2016 6:11 pm
- Been Liked: 2378 times
- Has Liked: 3801 times
- Location: Padiham
Re: Penalty?
The ball was not in play when the offence was committed
This user liked this post: IanMcL
-
- Posts: 25445
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 12:46 am
- Been Liked: 6930 times
- Has Liked: 11660 times
- Location: Leeds
Re: Penalty?
Because the ball wasn’t in play at that point at a guess.
How it was only a yellow is beyond me. Should have been another red.
How it was only a yellow is beyond me. Should have been another red.
-
- Posts: 25445
- Joined: Sat Mar 26, 2016 12:46 am
- Been Liked: 6930 times
- Has Liked: 11660 times
- Location: Leeds
Re: Penalty?
It was Frank, that answers that nice one.FactualFrank wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 5:41 pmI asked the same question pal before I realised.
It was out of play when it happened.
-
- Posts: 3554
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 11:15 am
- Been Liked: 1047 times
- Has Liked: 1187 times
- Location: Reading
Re: Penalty?
So far I have read he was thrown to the floor, punched in the face, slapped, jockeying for position.
All of which in law carry a very different sanction from nothing all the way up to a red card.
If as fans we cant decide as to what the offence is what chance has a referee got?
Wait he made his decision and that now should be the end of the matter. #Respect the decision.
Re: Penalty?
Never a pen as others have pointed out ... but definitely a sending off ... not just the push in Tarkas face but the theatrical comedy dive looking at the Ref to try and disguise what he had done...
As Souness said after the game "RED CARD"
As Souness said after the game "RED CARD"
-
- Posts: 25697
- Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2017 9:43 pm
- Been Liked: 4644 times
- Has Liked: 9849 times
- Location: Glasgow
Re: Penalty?
If the Xhaka offence was a red, then so should the Elneny offence have been, I'm not even sure what the defender was thinking, if you raise your hands in that way you're asking for trouble, fortunately for Arsenal the ref bottled it, how the VAR ref didn't direct him to view the monitor as he did with the Xhaka red card only he knows.
As others have stated it couldn't be a penalty as the ball wasn't in play at the time.
As others have stated it couldn't be a penalty as the ball wasn't in play at the time.
-
- Posts: 2256
- Joined: Sun Jan 24, 2016 10:41 am
- Been Liked: 426 times
- Has Liked: 219 times
Re: Penalty?
Defender throws himself to the floor despite him doing the fouling. Sure sign of guilt. I couldn’t believe he checked the screen and didn’t send him off. You can’t push someone on the face with two hands and get away with it. Or perhaps you can ..
-
- Posts: 67762
- Joined: Thu Dec 24, 2015 3:07 pm
- Been Liked: 32390 times
- Has Liked: 5270 times
- Location: Burnley
- Contact:
Re: Penalty?
I'm not sure how you can respect a decision when it's been looked at countless times and he gets it absolutely wrong. Two hands in the face of another player is violent conduct, nothing less, and Elneny just had to walk.dpinsussex wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 5:45 pmSo far I have read he was thrown to the floor, punched in the face, slapped, jockeying for position.
All of which in law carry a very different sanction from nothing all the way up to a red card.
If as fans we cant decide as to what the offence is what chance has a referee got?
Wait he made his decision and that now should be the end of the matter. #Respect the decision.
These 2 users liked this post: DomBFC1882 tiger76
-
- Posts: 2127
- Joined: Sat May 09, 2020 2:06 pm
- Been Liked: 352 times
- Has Liked: 294 times
Re: Penalty?
Can you imagine what the reaction would have been if Tarky had done it to Elneny.
The Arsenal bloke would still be rolling on the pitch now and the other players would
Have gone berserk, and a definite red.
The Arsenal bloke would still be rolling on the pitch now and the other players would
Have gone berserk, and a definite red.
-
- Posts: 3554
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 11:15 am
- Been Liked: 1047 times
- Has Liked: 1187 times
- Location: Reading
Re: Penalty?
In your opinion TonyClaretTony wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:05 pmI'm not sure how you can respect a decision when it's been looked at countless times and he gets it absolutely wrong. Two hands in the face of another player is violent conduct, nothing less, and Elneny just had to walk.
The referee didn't think it was violent.
That is football. Decisions are subjective.
As I mentioned on the other thread I felt Elneny was a very lucky boy
-
- Posts: 67762
- Joined: Thu Dec 24, 2015 3:07 pm
- Been Liked: 32390 times
- Has Liked: 5270 times
- Location: Burnley
- Contact:
Re: Penalty?
Then I honestly think he shouldn't be near a referee's whistle or VAR because that was as clear a red card as you are ever likely to see. I thought it was even worse than the first one and goodness knows why Scott wasn't even giving a yellow card for the foul.dpinsussex wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:10 pmIn your opinion Tony
The referee didn't think it was violent.
That is football. Decisions are subjective.
As I mentioned on the other thread I felt Elneny was a very lucky boy
-
- Posts: 15228
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 10:47 am
- Been Liked: 3155 times
- Has Liked: 6742 times
Re: Penalty?
I'm not sure about the ball not in play thing.
A player can be red-carded after the final whistle so why not while a corner is being taken?
A player can be red-carded after the final whistle so why not while a corner is being taken?
This user liked this post: tim_noone
-
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2017 2:21 pm
- Been Liked: 462 times
- Has Liked: 2398 times
Re: Penalty?
It’s the penalty that can’t be awarded as the ball is not in play until the corner is taken.boatshed bill wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:13 pmI'm not sure about the ball not in play thing.
A player can be red-carded after the final whistle so why not while a corner is being taken?
Like you say you can definitely be red carded.
And 100% this should have been a red card.
He struck Tarks in the face (red card in itself) but then feigned injury / being struck himself to try and get an opponent a card. All this was perfectly clear to the referee via VAR.
Everybody knows he bottled it purely because he had already sent one player off.
This user liked this post: GodIsADeeJay81
-
- Posts: 25697
- Joined: Sat Jun 24, 2017 9:43 pm
- Been Liked: 4644 times
- Has Liked: 9849 times
- Location: Glasgow
Re: Penalty?
Spot on TVC.TVC15 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:24 pmIt’s the penalty that can’t be awarded as the ball is not in play until the corner is taken.
Like you say you can definitely be red carded.
And 100% this should have been a red card.
He struck Tarks in the face (red card in itself) but then feigned injury / being struck himself to try and get an opponent a card. All this was perfectly clear to the referee via VAR.
Everybody knows he bottled it purely because he had already sent one player off.
-
- Posts: 15228
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 10:47 am
- Been Liked: 3155 times
- Has Liked: 6742 times
-
- Posts: 5869
- Joined: Wed Jan 27, 2016 6:39 pm
- Been Liked: 1695 times
- Has Liked: 2530 times
- Location: Rawtenstall
Re: Penalty?
Totally agree with this. I recall back in the late 90's we got a penalty at home to Blackpool early season when a corner was waiting to be taken. Different era, I know, but a player was wrestled to the ground, Kurt Nogan scored the penalty and we were 2-0 up. As for the referee seeing it as non-violent it would suggest he'd need to see blood to change his mind.boatshed bill wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:13 pmI'm not sure about the ball not in play thing.
A player can be red-carded after the final whistle so why not while a corner is being taken?
-
- Posts: 5869
- Joined: Wed Jan 27, 2016 6:39 pm
- Been Liked: 1695 times
- Has Liked: 2530 times
- Location: Rawtenstall
Re: Penalty?
Totally agree with this. I recall back in the late 90's we got a penalty at home to Blackpool early season when a corner was waiting to be taken. Different era, I know, but a player was wrestled to the ground, Kurt Nogan scored the penalty and we were 2-0 up. As for the referee seeing it as non-violent it would suggest he'd need to see blood to change his mind.boatshed bill wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:13 pmI'm not sure about the ball not in play thing.
A player can be red-carded after the final whistle so why not while a corner is being taken?
Edit.: Please remove this as it has been posted already.
-
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Sun Jan 24, 2016 5:27 pm
- Been Liked: 129 times
- Has Liked: 314 times
- Location: Dorset
Re: Penalty?
For clarity:
1. A penalty (or indeed a free kick) cannot be given if the ball is not in play. For example, awaiting a throw in, free kick or goal kick etc.
2. A red card can be given at any time, even if the ball is not in play.
It's always been the case.
1. A penalty (or indeed a free kick) cannot be given if the ball is not in play. For example, awaiting a throw in, free kick or goal kick etc.
2. A red card can be given at any time, even if the ball is not in play.
It's always been the case.
This user liked this post: dpinsussex
-
- Posts: 15228
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 10:47 am
- Been Liked: 3155 times
- Has Liked: 6742 times
Re: Penalty?
I posted nothing here
Re: Penalty?
Not sure - kind of makes sense to me.Silkyskills1 wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 6:49 pmTotally agree with this. I recall back in the late 90's we got a penalty at home to Blackpool early season when a corner was waiting to be taken. Different era, I know, but a player was wrestled to the ground, Kurt Nogan scored the penalty and we were 2-0 up. As for the referee seeing it as non-violent it would suggest he'd need to see blood to change his mind.
A penalty is a punishment for an infringement during play - just like a free kick. If the ball is not actually in play you are not really infringing anything so to speak.
The fact that it occurs in the area is kind of irrelevant - if a goal was scored for example and on the way back to the half way line somebody decided to spark out the scorer you would expect a red card but not for a free kick to be given. It’s no different in the area as there isn’t a ball on the pitch.
This user liked this post: boatshed bill
-
- Posts: 15228
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 10:47 am
- Been Liked: 3155 times
- Has Liked: 6742 times
Re: Penalty?
I remember a player (amateur league) being booked for jumping as high as he could in front of someone taking a throw in; ungentlemanly conduct. Can't remember if the throw in was retaken or a free kick given.
And plenty of us still recall the horrible challenge on our own Frank Casper when the ball was out of play.
And plenty of us still recall the horrible challenge on our own Frank Casper when the ball was out of play.
-
- Posts: 4406
- Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2016 12:13 am
- Been Liked: 1259 times
- Has Liked: 1368 times
Re: Penalty?
I must be mistaken, maybe you only like arguments when it is you that is trying to start
them.
Happy for you to confirm you weren't trying to be smart with the OP. If you can't do that I have no longer an interest in what you have to post.
Re: Penalty?
What exactly is the rule re a penalty eg when it can or cannot be given ?
1, if the ball had been placed by the corner flag and the ref had blown but the ball had not been kicked. Is it in play ?
2, if a player commits a foul tackle near the dead ball line inside the penalty but the ball goes over the dead ball line prior to the tackle. Is it a penalty
When is the ball actually in play and what does the rule say
1, if the ball had been placed by the corner flag and the ref had blown but the ball had not been kicked. Is it in play ?
2, if a player commits a foul tackle near the dead ball line inside the penalty but the ball goes over the dead ball line prior to the tackle. Is it a penalty
When is the ball actually in play and what does the rule say
Last edited by FCBurnley on Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Penalty?
There is a specific rule(s) about what an opposition player can and can’t do when facing a throw in.boatshed bill wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:12 pmI remember a player (amateur league) being booked for jumping as high as he could in front of someone taking a throw in; ungentlemanly conduct. Can't remember if the throw in was retaken or a free kick given.
And plenty of us still recall the horrible challenge on our own Frank Casper when the ball was out of play.
I heard about the awful challenge on Frank Casper but never saw it. What happened ?
-
- Posts: 16844
- Joined: Fri Jan 22, 2016 4:37 pm
- Been Liked: 6950 times
- Has Liked: 1479 times
- Location: Leeds
-
- Posts: 15228
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 10:47 am
- Been Liked: 3155 times
- Has Liked: 6742 times
Re: Penalty?
Hunter went right through him off the pitch, finished his career (although I believe he did play a few games but never the same).
Google it, you may get some footage.
-
- Posts: 11497
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 12:33 pm
- Been Liked: 3181 times
- Has Liked: 1864 times
- Contact:
Re: Penalty?
These are the IFAB rules re awarding of a penalty.FCBurnley wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:14 pmWhat exactly is the rule re a penalty eg when it can or cannot be given ?
1, if the ball had been placed by the corner flag and the ref had blown but the ball had not been kicked. Is it in play ?
2, if a player commits a foul tackle near the dead ball line inside the penalty but the ball goes over the dead ball line prior to the tackle. Is it a penalty
When is the ball actually in play and what does the rule say
The ball is only in play once the ball is kicked, not when the whistle is blown - this is why defending players can’t charge down the ball prior to a free kick being taken
- Attachments
-
- 9FA1A308-44B5-4CE0-82DB-F69B7476AB9E.jpeg (94.82 KiB) Viewed 2736 times
-
- Posts: 352
- Joined: Sun Jan 24, 2016 5:27 pm
- Been Liked: 129 times
- Has Liked: 314 times
- Location: Dorset
Re: Penalty?
A ball is deemed to be in play after it has been played by a free kick, throw in, goal kick etc. The referee blowing his whistle is merely to initiate a free kick, throw in etc.FCBurnley wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:14 pmWhat exactly is the rule re a penalty eg when it can or cannot be given ?
1, if the ball had been placed by the corner flag and the ref had blown but the ball had not been kicked. Is it in play ?
2, if a player commits a foul tackle near the dead ball line inside the penalty but the ball goes over the dead ball line prior to the tackle. Is it a penalty
When is the ball actually in play and what does the rule say
This user liked this post: dpinsussex
Re: Penalty?
If the ball has gone out of play it's no penalty, however bad the tackle. It's out of play as soon as the whole of the ball has crossed the whole of the line. Though the ref could, if he wanted to be legalese about it, give the penalty if the player started his attempt top foul while the ball was still in play, even if he didn't actually make contact until the ball had gone out.FCBurnley wrote: ↑Mon Dec 14, 2020 7:14 pmWhat exactly is the rule re a penalty eg when it can or cannot be given ?
1, if the ball had been placed by the corner flag and the ref had blown but the ball had not been kicked. Is it in play ?
2, if a player commits a foul tackle near the dead ball line inside the penalty but the ball goes over the dead ball line prior to the tackle. Is it a penalty
When is the ball actually in play and what does the rule say
Re: Penalty?
Thanks for the rules updates. So by my reckoning you can pin an attacker to the ground whilst waiting for a corner/ fk to be taken just as long as you release him before the kick is taken but you might get a yellow card as was the case yesterday at the Emirates lol
-
- Posts: 900
- Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2016 5:23 pm
- Been Liked: 291 times
- Has Liked: 99 times
Re: Penalty?
The real question is why did the ref not view the monitor? Fifa told the fa they have to do that for possible red card offences. But obviously when a big London club are involved you turn a blind eye. You can’t have THE arsenal playing wit nine men! That is scandalous!
Also note how no media has really covered the second offence too. Watched match of the day two and that annoying ‘chappers’ bloke said they aren't going to talk about that and just left it! The corruption and bias is so large in this league it is disgusting really. Imagine if it had been the other way around.
Also note how no media has really covered the second offence too. Watched match of the day two and that annoying ‘chappers’ bloke said they aren't going to talk about that and just left it! The corruption and bias is so large in this league it is disgusting really. Imagine if it had been the other way around.
Re: Penalty?
That would be a yellow card for ungentlemany conduct.FCBurnley wrote: ↑Tue Dec 15, 2020 12:05 amThanks for the rules updates. So by my reckoning you can pin an attacker to the ground whilst waiting for a corner/ fk to be taken just as long as you release him before the kick is taken but you might get a yellow card as was the case yesterday at the Emirates lol
Reading this and the other thread on the referee on Sunday shows that a large percentage of posters don't know or understand the rules of the game.
This user liked this post: dpinsussex
-
- Posts: 3779
- Joined: Fri Jan 15, 2016 9:15 am
- Been Liked: 1829 times
- Has Liked: 2623 times
- Location: Ashington, Northumberland
Re: Penalty?
It doesn't stop them from giving marks for referees when the opportunity is there.
Having said that, with the way that David Elleray and IFAB have messed around with The Laws of the Game and their interpretation in the last four years, much of them relating to VAR, it is no surprise.
It is a topic of conversation at every monthly meeting of our local Referees' Association and every video which is shown prompts several different views and it is certainly not helping with the development of young referees.
This user liked this post: dpinsussex
-
- Posts: 7310
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 5:06 pm
- Been Liked: 1827 times
- Has Liked: 3964 times
Re: Penalty?
Maybe wrong, but my interpretation of the MOTD comment was that he wasn't discussing if further because it was so clearly a red card, and that was what the commentator had said. There are loads of incidents that they don't show again.thelaughingclaret wrote: ↑Tue Dec 15, 2020 6:06 amWatched match of the day two and that annoying ‘chappers’ bloke said they aren't going to talk about that and just left it! The corruption and bias is so large in this league it is disgusting really. Imagine if it had been the other way around.
-
- Posts: 9459
- Joined: Sun Oct 16, 2016 10:47 pm
- Been Liked: 1183 times
- Has Liked: 778 times
Re: Penalty?
It’s not a case of not knowing nor any lack of understanding it’s more down to the rules changing & being inconsistent, how anybody keeps track of what is what is beyond me, half of the so called rules are just made up as you go along.
-
- Posts: 1865
- Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2016 1:33 pm
- Been Liked: 383 times
- Has Liked: 234 times
- Location: Skipton
Re: Penalty?
Law 12 is ridiculous. It means 'anything goes' until the ball is kicked!
-
- Posts: 5869
- Joined: Wed Jan 27, 2016 6:39 pm
- Been Liked: 1695 times
- Has Liked: 2530 times
- Location: Rawtenstall
Re: Penalty?
It wasn't so long ago, at the start of a new season, I remember a spate of penalties being awarded for infringements in the penalty area less severe than the one on Sunday night. Mike Dean especially springs to mind as being a referee not afraid to punish the defending side. Were the rules changed again after that?
-
- Posts: 11497
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 12:33 pm
- Been Liked: 3181 times
- Has Liked: 1864 times
- Contact:
Re: Penalty?
It doesn't mean "anything goes"Im_not_Robbie_Blake wrote: ↑Tue Dec 15, 2020 10:13 amLaw 12 is ridiculous. It means 'anything goes' until the ball is kicked!
You can still receive either a yellow or red card, it just wont be resulting in a penalty.
This user liked this post: IanMcL
-
- Posts: 838
- Joined: Thu Jan 21, 2016 9:55 pm
- Been Liked: 246 times
- Has Liked: 118 times
Re: Penalty?
Let us just be thankful everything went as it did. Westy first corner looked to be going far too deep. If he hadn't been fouled,maybe Tarks could have got to it, maybe not. If they had defended the second corner with 9 men they would probably have been standing in slightly different places when it was taken, maybe we wouldn't have scored.