Should Niang have been sent off?

[claretspice]

Any evidence of that? If he did, he should have been booked.

[Ashingtonclaret46]

Ashley Barnes was not booked in the Palace game.

[taio]

You can either take my word for it that he and the other players ended up with the crowd in JML or you can find the evidence that you require yourself. I can remember it as clear as day because it was my favourite moment this season.


Here you go:

https://www.thesun.co.uk/video/football ... al-palace/

How many of our players should have been booked? None, Barnes or all of them?

[Tall Paul]

The rule is the excessive celebration one and the interpretation given to referees, which players and managers are also made aware of, is that running into the crowd will result in a yellow card.

If that were the case, it shouldn't be that hard to find a link to prove it.

It also doesn't make sense that it isn't included on the list of actions which a player must be cautioned for as listed above.

[claretspice]

You can either take my word for it that he and the other players ended up with the crowd in JML or you can find the evidence that you require yourself. I can remember it as clear as day because it was my favourite moment this season.


Here you go:

https://www.thesun.co.uk/video/football ... al-palace/

How many of our players should have been booked? None, Barnes or all of them?

As i recall, and that video i'd inconclusive, Barnes didn't climb onto the stand to seek out the crowd. The crowd came to him. Thats a pretty key distinction. I might be wrong, and certainly if i am then it should have been a yellow for Barnes, yes, but i think that is your answer.

[cricketfieldclarets]

Send him down

[Shore claret]

I think all celebrating is excessive, you should just run back and get on with the game.
Bloody show ponies the lot of them.
Ward should of rolled around on the floor with his hands up and arched his back several times, just like there player. Particularly liked it how he took him out then just ran off, not bothering to see how the player was, classy.

[claretspice]

Send him down

If thay photo is of the same incident, then looks like i was right - clearly not in the crowd, just that crowd members have come to the players.

Paul - there's a difference between what the rules expressly say and what the clubs and players are clearly told in briefings will be the interpretation.

[cricketfieldclarets]

If thay photo is of the same incident, then looks like i was right - clearly not in the crowd, just that crowd members have come to the players.

Paul - there's a difference between what the rules expressly say and what the clubs and players are clearly told in briefings will be the interpretation.

Its overexubberant

[THEWELLERNUT70]

In answer to the op

I thought that Niang challenge on Ward early on was a boardeline red and the Cathcart one late on on Brady was every bit as bad as the Hendrick one and he should have been sent off