RATE THE REF - Bobby Madley v Plymouth Argyle

[jdrobbo]

BOBBY MADLEY[/b (South Yorkshire) v Plymouth Argyle


HOW TO SCORE

A. Decision Making (including use of advantage) - out of 25
B. Consistency - out of 25
C. Fitness and Positioning - of 25
D. Control and Authority - out of 25





Please only Rate the Ref if you attended the game and only do so, after the game has ended. Thank you

[jdrobbo]

A 21
B 22
C 20
D 24

[Aclaret]

Couldn't make tonight's game, so off tv, it wasn't too difficult a game, decent performance from Bob.......not sure about 98mins though !

[MDWat]

A - 20
B - 25
C - 20
D - 25

[MeeActon1]

23
23
23
23

[TheFamilyCat]

I never do the ratings, but think he had a good game. Got the one big decision right and let the game flow instead of blowing for every little coming together.

[FCBurnley]

Total homer lol

[Rowls]

Thought he was very good tonight.

A. 21
B. 18
C. 17
D. 20

[MrTopTier]

22
22
20
22

How a game should be reffed.

[Bosscat]

21
20
21
20

Controlled the game well tonight

[sjb]

20
20
20
20

Chalk & cheese re that clown against Pompey

[quoonbeatz]

He’s a decent ref is Madley, had quite a few good performances with us in recent times.

[xxmunkyennuixx]

Best I've seen for ages, since Oliver away at Arsenal.

A - 24
B - 23
C - 22
D - 25

[ClaretTony]

Webb and Linington should be made to sit and watch this performance - he was spot on with most things tonight

A. 23
B. 23
C. 23
D. 24

[IanMcL]

Easy match to ref, as players respected each other and the ref. Good performance.

[Juan Tanamera]

24
24
24
24

It always seems easier to give a referee good marks when your team has won but Madley's performance tonight was excellent.
Fair play to Plymouth and Rooney for playing in the right spirit without any of the antics we saw from Portsmouth the other week.

[Poulton-le-Claret]

20
23
23
24

Sound performance, who needs var.

[nil_desperandum]

Couldn't make tonight's game, so off tv, it wasn't too difficult a game, decent performance from Bob.......not sure about 98mins though !

How many minutes do you think there should have been?
The board went up for 6 minutes and then the game was stopped for about 2
I thought 6 was about right but it could have been more, and we played about 6.

[Goobs]

22
23
22
25

[ClaretLoup]

A 24 - should have booked Brownhill for hauling a player back
B 25
C 25
D 25

[Luppy]

A - 24. His use of the advantage rule in particular was excellent all night for both sides
B - 23
C - 23
D - 23

An excellent performance

[Bordeauxclaret]

Best ref we’ve had for a good while.

[DAVETHEVICAR]

Great to see these high marks for a top class referee who had a great match between 2 teams who played with honesty and no rolling on floor and time wasting

[burnley007]

Easy match to ref, as players respected each other and the ref. Good performance.

I think the ref played a part in that though, he allowed certain things to go, but players knew the line. It was an excellent performance.

Although I don't think Lyle would agree!

[ClaretLoup]

Lyle needs to watch a few Basher Barnes videos to learn his trade.

[THEWELLERNUT70]

An excellent job done throughout imo

[Rick_Muller]

From the TV and with the benefit of replays I was extremely impressed with the ref, as far as I could see he got everything right, including the additional 2 minutes at the end because there was a substitution in injury time wasn't there? so he just added the time on which is correct and something we've been calling for for years.

[ClaretTony]

From the TV and with the benefit of replays I was extremely impressed with the ref, as far as I could see he got everything right, including the additional 2 minutes at the end because there was a substitution in injury time wasn't there? so he just added the time on which is correct and something we've been calling for for years.

They put six up for the added minutes while the game was stopped. It was another one minute and forty seconds before we restarted so the added time to added time was absolutely correct.

[BurnleyFC]

Richard and Judy’s lad had a good game.

[Beagleheart]

23
23
21
22