Anyone recommend a good one?

To say its one of our traditional dishes dont half end up with some hit and miss places. Fish and chips on the other hand you can almost always find a good one.

Had one today in Lancaster that looked and sounded promising but was a bit meh. Almost always end up let down. Either too small, crap quality or both.

Can never beat a proper home cooked one. But looking for recommendations for next time we go out for one.

One on the list is The George near Harrogate but the bloody a59 is closed for some reason atm. If anyone can recommend either way will be aiming to go soon.

The Buck Inn at Malham. Do the walk up to Janets Foss and onto Gordale Scar, either to build up a hunger or to walk off the meal.

Don't try and kid me with Dinner... it's Tea!

Talking of Harrogate, there's a nice Italian up the hill on the left from the main theatre. I guess a name would help, but it escapes me.

I have always liked the hare and hounds in foulridge since taken over by those that had the new inn.....I had a very good sunday lunch last year....you can have a mix of chicken/beef and gammon if you are hungry and price is very reasonable....not been for a few months though.

FactualFrank wrote:Don't try and kid me with Dinner... it's Tea!

Talking of Harrogate, there's a nice Italian up the hill on the left from the main theatre. I guess a name would help, but it escapes me.

Well I was going to mention sunday roast but didnt fancy the inevitable innuendo!

piston broke wrote:The Buck Inn at Malham. Do the walk up to Janets Foss and onto Gordale Scar, either to build up a hunger or to walk off the meal.

Cracking walk. And an amazing part of the world any time of year. On the list!

Actually at the end of the walk before you head to the foss they have a little sandwich van that actually does roast dinner sandwiches for about £4. Absolutely belting too!

happyclaret17 wrote:I have always liked the hare and hounds in foulridge since taken over by those that had the new inn.....I had a very good sunday lunch last year....you can have a mix of chicken/beef and gammon if you are hungry and price is very reasonable....not been for a few months though.

Heard good things but never got round to it. Now on the list too

edit - was recommended by my mate who eats so much meat (and other fine food) he has constant gout and also by a butcher. So definitely on the list now!

Lurpak ...T cake....Salt & Vinegar crisps....lovely.

Steve1956 wrote:Lurpak ...T cake....Salt & Vinegar crisps....lovely.

There's enough salt in the Lurpak. Just go with plain crisps.

FactualFrank wrote:There's enough salt in the Lurpak. Just go with plain crisps.

Another one..Lurpak ..T cake...Sugar.

Pretty much pointless going out for Sunday dinner. The roast meat has to be kept warm, as do the roast spuds (drys them out and kills flavour) and then the veg has to be cooked at the last minute, but they all take different amounts of time. Hard enough for a home cook doing one dish, impossible for a commercial kitchen.

Make the it yourself, or accept disappointment

Good Yorkshire fish n chips. From Skipton.

lrac wrote:Good Yorkshire fish n chips. From Skipton.

Skipton? Nah, that's for the ice cream!

cricketfieldclarets wrote:Anyone recommend a good one?

To say its one of our traditional dishes dont half end up with some hit and miss places. Fish and chips on the other hand you can almost always find a good one.

Had one today in Lancaster that looked and sounded promising but was a bit meh. Almost always end up let down. Either too small, crap quality or both.

Can never beat a proper home cooked one. But looking for recommendations for next time we go out for one.

Good fish and chips aren’t so easy to find, especially after a night match at Burnley. For a simple dish, it’s amazing how many don’t either do it right or buy / use the wrong products:

Cheap fish
Vegetable oil
Margarine on bread

I’m sure there will be some, but I’ve not had great fish and chips from any around Turf Moor.

DCWat wrote:Good fish and chips aren’t so easy to find, especially after a night match at Burnley. For a simple dish, it’s amazing how many don’t either do it right or buy / use the wrong products:

Cheap fish
Vegetable oil
Margarine on bread

I’m sure there will be some, but I’ve not had great fish and chips from any around Turf Moor.

Stand back a second. Are you actually asking people to cook or throw more than a couple of things into a pot?

The most over-rated of meals.. ..two thirds of the plate is cheap vegetables [sometimes over-cooked mush] and if you have an unlucky day, you can get chewy beef or fatty lamb.

- not for me generally, though if you get a really good one, nice and hot, then fair enough.

Elains tearooms at Feizor (just past Settle)

1fatclaret wrote:Pretty much pointless going out for Sunday dinner. The roast meat has to be kept warm, as do the roast spuds (drys them out and kills flavour) and then the veg has to be cooked at the last minute, but they all take different amounts of time. Hard enough for a home cook doing one dish, impossible for a commercial kitchen.

Make the it yourself, or accept disappointment

Nailed it.

I can count on one hand the number of decent Sunday Roasts I've had in pubs and restaurants.

Carveries are crappy, shoddy places to eat.

You've got to hope to blind luck with the kitchen and arrive just at the moment the meat and roasties are ready to serve.

1fatclaret wrote:Pretty much pointless going out for Sunday dinner. The roast meat has to be kept warm, as do the roast spuds (drys them out and kills flavour) and then the veg has to be cooked at the last minute, but they all take different amounts of time. Hard enough for a home cook doing one dish, impossible for a commercial kitchen.

Make the it yourself, or accept disappointment

Explains the perrenial disapointment and why the home cooked ones unbeatable.

Saying that a good place should still be able to work out approximately what they need and when.

DCWat wrote:Good fish and chips aren’t so easy to find, especially after a night match at Burnley. For a simple dish, it’s amazing how many don’t either do it right or buy / use the wrong products:

Cheap fish
Vegetable oil
Margarine on bread

I’m sure there will be some, but I’ve not had great fish and chips from any around Turf Moor.

Around Burnley absolutely agree. Further afield consistently get excellent fish and chips.

Probably becauee of the opposite reasons 1fat makes above. Its quick easy and cooked to order.

hampsteadclaret wrote:The most over-rated of meals.. ..two thirds of the plate is cheap vegetables [sometimes over-cooked mush] and if you have an unlucky day, you can get chewy beef or fatty lamb.

- not for me generally, though if you get a really good one, nice and hot, then fair enough.

Had the opposite yesterday. Chewy lamb and fatty beef

White Swan, Wheatley Lane
one of the best have had in the North

Calf's Head at Worsten off the A59. Faultless.

Mine end of, my Granddaughter says so. No matter where we eat she will say " not as good as yours Granddad"

Higher Buck at Waddington or the Bonney Inn at Salesbury are both excellent .....

It is Sunday lunch in Burnley don't you know?.

The Carvery in Montemar, just 5 minutes walk from Benalmadina Marina on the Costa Del Sol is the best in Europe! Definitely worth a visit if you are on your Holiday's and in that area this summer. Don't forget to ring and book though.

Another vote for the White Swan in Fence. The Yorkshires alone make it worth the visit.

I don't go on holiday to have a f*cking sunday dinner

KateR wrote:White Swan, Wheatley Lane
one of the best have had in the North

Heard its quite expensive....how much for the sunday dinner ?

cricketfieldclarets wrote:Had the opposite yesterday. Chewy lamb and fatty beef

Where is the nearest decent one open after a night match? We head out over the tops back ‘over to the other side of the hill’ but even heading main road ways, we never see one open.

Fish & chips on a Sunday. That's just not right.

As bad as having Sunday lunch on a Tuesday

the grouse inn quality.

The one on the right on way to Todmorden is good on price for a very fair sunday dinner....its a free house so they dont have to charge silly money.....far from posh but you can pay a lot more for the same or worse......that huge mixed grill is only for the really hungry and they also do suet puddings.

UpTheBeehole wrote:I don't go on holiday to have a f*cking sunday dinner

I know what you mean Beehole. The food is that good, that you get 50% of the local Spanish in the Restaurant. I once went on holiday and had a f*cking English Breakfast!

The new waggoners

Ship inn Sandside

Smithy Inn Holme

DCWat wrote:Where is the nearest decent one open after a night match? We head out over the tops back ‘over to the other side of the hill’ but even heading main road ways, we never see one open.

Fish and chips?

DCWat wrote:Where is the nearest decent one open after a night match? We head out over the tops back ‘over to the other side of the hill’ but even heading main road ways, we never see one open.

Most English chippy's close at 6.30pm, which is strange to say the least.

happyclaret17 wrote:The one on the right on way to Todmorden is good on price for a very fair sunday dinner....its a free house so they dont have to charge silly money.....far from posh but you can pay a lot more for the same or worse......that huge mixed grill is only for the really hungry and they also do suet puddings.

Glen View?

KateR wrote:White Swan, Wheatley Lane
one of the best have had in the North

Have eaten there but not Sunday roast and food was excellent. Dont they have a michelin star now?

Also went past on NYE when we went for a walk. It was closed but we tried the door. They let us in and served us while they were busy setting up for the night. Seemed like very nice people who know how to look after customers. Plus one for my two experiences there.

If you're a decent cook, its going to be really hard for a commercial kitchen to nail the core elements of a roast to the level you can do at home. The meat can be served perfect (a lot still get this wrong), but they aren't going to be roasting potatoes and veg to order . ..you'd be waiting too long. A kitchen can produce a decent effort though... a cracking couple of sides can help elevate. I think the white swan do a bit of bone marrow and a good cauli cheese. A lot of places that do a large amount of volume on a sunday will just churn out the standard fayre though.

I don't tend to order them if im honest.

Indecisive wrote:If you're a decent cook, its going to be really hard for a commercial kitchen to nail the core elements of a roast to the level you can do at home. The meat can be served perfect (a lot still get this wrong), but they aren't going to be roasting potatoes and veg to order . ..you'd be waiting too long. A kitchen can produce a decent effort though... a cracking couple of sides can help elevate. I think the white swan do a bit of bone marrow and a good cauli cheese. A lot of places that do a large amount of volume on a sunday will just churn out the standard fayre though.

I don't tend to order them if im honest.

Another simple explanation as to why my mrs is always ****** off when we go out for sunday dinner. Her favourite. She thinks Im having her on when I say we are better going for curry!

cricketfieldclarets wrote:Glen View?

thats the one....cheap and very fair.

Glen View food looks enticing but the place itself is an absolute dump. We tried to get a table and was sat with the pub regulars who then had a go about why were sitting in "their" pub area. Such a shame as the food looked good, but we left before we ordered.

happyclaret17 wrote:The one on the right on way to Todmorden is good on price for a very fair sunday dinner....its a free house so they dont have to charge silly money....s.far from posh but you can pay a lot more for the same or worse......that huge mixed grill is only for the really hungry and they also do suet puddings.

Have to second that. The Glen View does fab pub food, and good prices too.

Toilets are a bit "Longside" but never mind that, the food is A+++ for pub standard

ClaretAL wrote:Glen View food looks enticing but the place itself is an absolute dump. We tried to get a table and was sat with the pub regulars who then had a go about why were sitting in "their" pub area. Such a shame as the food looked good, but we left before we ordered.

How did you order after you left?

cricketfieldclarets wrote:Anyone recommend a good one?
Had one today in Lancaster that looked and sounded promising but was a bit meh.

I thoroughly recommend The Fenwick Arms at Claughton the next time you're up that way.

cricketfieldclarets wrote:Fish and chips?

Aye