Barnes v Jay rod

[Six fingers]

Just thinking who the better player is
Goal scored
Minutes play
Anyone got a clue ?

[MRG]

Jay Rod is a different level. Next Question?

[tim_noone]

You've left Hancock out?

[Vino blanco]

Haven't got a clue about statistics, but I am certain Jayrod is a much better player, who would walk into our starting eleven.

[ClaretTony]

Totally different players

[CombatClaret]

Jay Rod is a different level. Next Question?

Players form rises and falls. Going off 2014 form I'd agree, last season though.

JayRod - 2800mins 7 Goals
Barnes - 2150mins 9 goals

[DustyBawls]

Totally different players

I was thinking the same thing. Might as well compare 2 similar sorts of players at least.

[Vegas Claret]

completely different players with different skill sets, Jay would massively improve our options

[DustyBawls]

I think Wood and Jay would make a good partnership.

[MRG]

Players form rises and falls. Going off 2014 form I'd agree, last season though.

JayRod - 2800mins 7 Goals
Barnes - 2150mins 9 goals

Apologies I misread the question. I thought the question was who is the better player not who has the better goals per min ratio

[Diesel]

When Barnes is fully fit, only an idiot would leave him out the team, he was absolutely brilliant last year.

[Colburn_Claret]

Might as well compare Cahill and Heaton.

Both great players, but different styles.
Jay a better footballer, Barnes a bigger pain in the arse, and no slouch.

P.S. I'd like them both. The difference between Jay and another forward, is you could find a place for him in the team alongside any of the other strikers, it doesn't mean the bench for anyone.

[GodIsADeeJay81]

A front three from Jay, Wood, Barnes and Vokes when we are chasing a game would be interesting.