Just thinking who the better player is
Goal scored
Minutes play
Anyone got a clue ?

Jay Rod is a different level. Next Question?

You've left Hancock out?

Haven't got a clue about statistics, but I am certain Jayrod is a much better player, who would walk into our starting eleven.

Totally different players

MRG wrote:Jay Rod is a different level. Next Question?

Players form rises and falls. Going off 2014 form I'd agree, last season though.

JayRod - 2800mins 7 Goals
Barnes - 2150mins 9 goals

ClaretTony wrote:Totally different players

I was thinking the same thing. Might as well compare 2 similar sorts of players at least.

completely different players with different skill sets, Jay would massively improve our options

I think Wood and Jay would make a good partnership.

CombatClaret wrote:Players form rises and falls. Going off 2014 form I'd agree, last season though.

JayRod - 2800mins 7 Goals
Barnes - 2150mins 9 goals

Apologies I misread the question. I thought the question was who is the better player not who has the better goals per min ratio

When Barnes is fully fit, only an idiot would leave him out the team, he was absolutely brilliant last year.

Might as well compare Cahill and Heaton.

Both great players, but different styles.
Jay a better footballer, Barnes a bigger pain in the arse, and no slouch.

P.S. I'd like them both. The difference between Jay and another forward, is you could find a place for him in the team alongside any of the other strikers, it doesn't mean the bench for anyone.

A front three from Jay, Wood, Barnes and Vokes when we are chasing a game would be interesting.