RATE THE REF - Anthony Backhouse v Sunderland

[jdrobbo]

Anthony Backhouse (Cumbria) v Sunderland

How to Score
A. Decision Making (including use of advantage) - out of 25
B. Consistency - out of 25
C. Fitness and Positioning - of 25
D. Control and Authority - out of 25


Please only Rate the Ref if you attended the game and only do so, after the game has ended.

[Aclaret]

Unlucky Mr Backhouse....you did your best to beat us.

[Milltown1882]

0 0 0 0

1 point to take back on the Sunderland coach

[123EasyasBFC]

No need to rate the ref, just absolutely shite all night

[box_of_frogs]

Oh, this is a serious thread.

[RammyClaret61]

0 0 0 0

1 point to take back on the Sunderland coach

Only watched second half. Got to agree with you, although 0000 might be a generous.

[BurnleyFC]

Lee Mason-esque from this fat, little useless ******.

I hope he stands on a plug.

[Hedontplayforyou]

Rate the ref? ******* HELL!

[Longsider]

Tw@t

[Rowls]

I thought he was good - for 70 minutes.

I'll mark properly later.

[Taffy on the wing]

I thought he was good - for 70 minutes.

I'll mark properly later.

Was that the 70 mins before kick off?

[Lip]

-25
-25
-25
-25
What a chunt!

[Goobs]

A. 3
B. 2
C. 10
D. 9

[RalphCoatesComb]

Don't think I've ever seen a worse performance.

"Backhouse"... perhaps it should be "Backhander"

Was that the 70 mins before kick off?

[THEWELLERNUT70]

I thought he was good - for 70 minutes.

I'll mark properly later.

We're you stuck in traffic and listening to it on the radio

[CrosspoolClarets]

A-1 Many crucial decisions wrong including a penalty for us and for them
B-1 Too much missed from SAFC, and it should have been us given the penalty not them (Flemming)
C-5 Can only assume positioning was bad, either that or he was a blind ref
D-5 Didnt show a yellow till late despite constant niggles

A rank ref who ruined the game, probably cost us a win (we barely deserved) and nearly handed it to them through incompetence.

[xxmunkyennuixx]

I normally rate but wasn't at the Turf. He was ****. Missed pen on Flemming and two that shouldn't have stood. He'd be below five on decision making.

[fungus_the_bogeyman]

A 5
B 5
C 5
D 5

Up there with Kevin Lynch, Trevor Kettle and Lee Mason. Absolutely dreadful!

[dougcollins]

A 5
B 5
C 5
D 5

Up there with Kevin Lynch, Trevor Kettle and Lee Mason. Absolutely dreadful!

Two out of those three admitted they didn’t like Burnley.

I wonder what this guy’s excuse was.

[SouthLondonexile]

0
0
0
0

[HurstGrangeClaret]

The referee got a lot wrong. Not sure there was enough in the Fleming one to give a penalty.
The two Sunderland penalties were wrong. Ref can only give them if he’s sure. First one clearly outside the box, and maybe CJ lucky not to see a red card. Second one is very dubious so the ref has guessed both decisions.
Having said all that, massive well done to JT, maybe taking gamesmanship to the limit but who cares. And secondly the block by CJ in the 93rd minute was just sensational.
All in all, not a great performance but still a point against a very good Sunderland side.
UTC.

[Claretrew]

No I didn't.

[Silkyskills1]

'Not sure there was enough in the Flemming one'

What does that actually mean? It's either a foul or not a foul. Do fouls have a grading system? Anywhere else on the pitch that is a foul so why the doubt in the penalty box? Not a bad referee but rather a disgraceful one enjoying the limelight on a Friday evening.

[Cheshireclaret]

I’m not going to bother rating him - he was an absolute stinker of a ref who should be ashamed and embarrassed at that performance tonight. But no, he’ll be back reffing midweek somewhere.

Also a special mention for the linesman in front of The Longside - he absolutely 100% should have known it was outside the box, how the hell did he not say anything?

[Bordeauxclaret]

Awful performance.

We are stuck with VAR in a lot of football because of people like this.

[HurstGrangeClaret]

'Not sure there was enough in the Flemming one'

What does that actually mean? It's either a foul or not a foul. Do fouls have a grading system? Anywhere else on the pitch that is a foul so why the doubt in the penalty box? Not a bad referee but rather a disgraceful one enjoying the limelight on a Friday evening.

If a similar one had been given against us, you would have criticised it.
Pity the ref wasn’t as scrupulous when awarding the Sunderland pens.

[Goodclaret]

I think I'll give him:

0
0
3
5

That really was an awful "performance". I always say I can (kind of) get when a ref has missed something so therefore not made a decision it's forgivable but to give two pens when neither are then he has clearly guessed and that is definitely the sign of a true bad un. Maybe it was his first game in front of the Sky camera's so was unduly excitable but it really was an awful evening for him.

[ClaretTony]

A. 4
B. 6
C. 8
D. 4

Absolutely appalling right from the start. For what it's worth, I don't think Flemming's is a pen but if the second Sunderland one is then Flemming's is worth three. As for their first penalty, how on earth do he and the lino not get that right between them.

One free kick we won in the first half despite foul after foul which of course were not given.

Shocking referee

[quoonbeatz]

We’re all used to the incredibly low standards of referees in this country but it’s still a surprise when they give plus someone who plumbs new depths like this wasteman.

No understanding of the game or the laws. Ridiculously weak - how did Ballard not get a 2nd yellow at the end? Neither penalty is a penalty. Constant shirt pulling, which he occasionally pulled up but where were the cards?

It’s a good job justice was done with the penalties because this was a disgraceful performance from the officials. The liners were both crap as well.

[LincsWoldsClaret]

This year’s winner of the Tony Harrington Award for the Most Inept and Incompetent Refereeing Performance goes to…

Tony Backhouse

Just how clueless can you get

[sjb]

0
0
10
5

I thought the Sonne penalty was probably correct but as for the other 2 decisions - sheer incompetence.

[Luppy]

A - 2 -
B - 4
C - 6
D - 2

As bad as I’ve seen, though not helped by his assistants or 4th official

The first is never a penalty but surely the liner has to help him out there - surely? It’s not even close

The second I actually thought he’d given for handball but having got home and watched it on sky he’s clearly given it for a foul. There is no foul! Nobody knows what he’s given in the first instance. Absolutely laughable. The full back steps into Sonne - joke

If the second challenge is a penalty then the challenge on Flemming is 100% a penalty. Just staggering he can wave that away and give theirs

Ballard at the end. He’s been booked and then completely wipes Cullen out - ok it’s late on, but it’s a second yellow all day long. He has to send him off - nothing

The foul on Roberts which again is nowhere near the ball, it’s naughty, it’s probably a yellow. What’s the 4th official doing? It’s clearly, clearly a foul and they play on with Sunderland in possession.

A shambles from start to finish - embarrassing. If he and his team go home and watch that back tomorrow and are anything other than embarrassed I’ll be amazed

[nonayclaret]

A) 5
B) 8
C) 15
D) 3

[Cirrus_Minor]

Absolute shocker. The first penalty was outside the box (although i did think at first it was inside, but i am way back in the upper tier not a referee/linesman within ysrds of the action). The second seemed to be incredibly soft.
I was also wondering at one stage in the first half if we were ever going to get a free kick.

A 7
B 4
C 12
D 4

[RalphCoatesComb]

If he and his team go home and watch that back tomorrow and are anything other than embarrassed I’ll be amazed

I'll be amazed if he isn't dropped for next week's games.

[bobinho]

I thought he had a great game.
Then there were two penalty shouts…
First looked nailed on. No problem ref well done. Turns out it was outside the box.
Second one looked like a poor challenge, turns out there was NO challenge.

Dunno what to score him.

[martin_p]

Worst performance I’ve seen from a referee at the Turf for a long, long time!

[mybloodisclaret]

A - 1
B - 2
C - 1
D - 1

Absolutely terrible. From start to finish. Completely and utterly ruined the game.

He won't be fined or punished for that abortion of a performance, no rather that he will get a game to ruin next week and still get paid far more than me and the majority of clarets on here.

[MDWat]

A - 3
B - 3
C - 3
D - 3

I thought their second penalty was the correct decision but he still absolutely honked the whole way through. Dreadful.

[DCWat]

I’m not sure we got a free kick until around the 34th minute.

I’ve no problem with referees let the game flow, but in doing so, they have to be consistent. He wasn’t.

The penalties were poor decisions - Sonne’s was very soft - if that’s a penalty, the Flemming one should have been too. Really, neither were enough for a penalty, for me.

The first one was a shocker. I just can’t see how he can have been so certain, so quickly. What was his linesman watching!?

Decisions like these, on live TV. He really should be questioned on his performance. He won’t be, he’ll probably be in the PL in a year or two!

[agreenwood]

A. 4
B. 6
C. 8
D. 4

Absolutely appalling right from the start. For what it's worth, I don't think Flemming's is a pen but if the second Sunderland one is then Flemming's is worth three. As for their first penalty, how on earth do he and the lino not get that right between them.

One free kick we won in the first half despite foul after foul which of course were not given.

Shocking referee

It took him 34 minutes to award us a free kick. Can’t remember anything like it.

[jdrobbo]

This year’s winner of the Tony Harrington Award for the Most Inept and Incompetent Refereeing Performance goes to…

Tony Backhouse

Just how clueless can you get

Brilliant

[Damo]

Also a special mention for the linesman in front of The Longside - he absolutely 100% should have known it was outside the box, how the hell did he not say anything?

The liner in front of the North stand had a great view of several wrong decisions and bottled out of raising his flag. He was an absolute chocolate fireguard.

As for Backhouse. He was absolutely dreadful.

1
15
3
3

[dsr]

5 - 0 - 10 - 2

His only defence is that his linesman was as bad.

Even before the late meltdown, his free kick decisions were random. And his mental coin flip came down Sunderland side up too often for my liking.

[CrosspoolClarets]

Would like to give my thanks to Anthony Backhander for that first pen, because that was CJ suspended for Plymouth and maybe Leeds (unsure if it is 2) because if that was a freekick it is a red, but a penalty there has to be no challenge for a red, unless I have misunderstood the rules?

[Rileybobs]

We’ve had much worse. Anything else is recency bias. But apart from the hideous first penalty decision, and questionable second, the rest of his performance was so random. There was no logic or consistency with the majority of his decisions. To not send Ballard off at the end was just incomprehensible.

[dsr]

Would like to give my thanks to Anthony Backhander for that first pen, because that was CJ suspended for Plymouth and maybe Leeds (unsure if it is 2) because if that was a freekick it is a red, but a penalty there has to be no challenge for a red, unless I have misunderstood the rules?

It's anybody's guess what the ref thought he saw. But he surely can't have imagined that Egan-Riley was making a tackle when his leg touched the forward's, in which case it would have been a red card whether penalty or free kick - unless, as was presumably the case, the ref believed that it was not a clear goalscoring opportunity. Perhaps that Trafford would have got to the ball first, or that the other defender provided cover.

What I don't agree with is why it was a foul anyway. The two players' legs barely touched, though it was enough to knock the Sunderland man's left leg on to his right and trip himself up. How does an official decide, when Smith and Jones who are moving to the same spot, touch each other - who is the toucher and who is the touchee?

[bfcmik]

A. 8
B. 8
C. 20
D. 20

[FCBurnley]

Don't think I've ever seen a worse performance.

"Backhouse"... perhaps it should be "Backhander"

Was that the 70 mins before kick off?

Or Shithouse

[FCBurnley]

Anthony Shithouse. The man who makes VAR look perfect