BOBBY MADLEY (South Yorkshire) v Derby County


HOW TO SCORE

A. Decision Making (including use of advantage) - out of 25
B. Consistency - out of 25
C. Fitness and Positioning - of 25
D. Control and Authority - out of 25





Please only Rate the Ref if you attended the game and only do so, after the game has ended. Thank you

A 17
B 11
C 16
D 16

Wasn't there. But I thought he missed foul after foul after foul

12
8
16
10

Pretty poor tonight.

Shite

A 14
B 11
C 20
D 13

Clown

From the TV ... Madley was his usual self & missed loads.

Average performance from the man from Otley (I think)

A - 10
B - 5
C - 12
D - 15

Played into their hands. Gave 14 fouls against us and 8 against them despite their physicality.

3
3
20
20

Allowed it to become a rugby match

Madley was averagely bad. But I thought the assistants on either side didn't help him in the slightest and we're absolutely awful.

A special mention for that awful rule about not flagging till an offside player touches the ball. That one later in the second half he let Yates battle with our defence before flagging was a joke.

CrosspoolClarets wrote: ↑

Tue Apr 08, 2025 10:51 pm

A - 10
B - 5
C - 12
D - 15

Played into their hands. Gave 14 fouls against us and 8 against them despite their physicality.

Everywhere has that the opposite way round. 14 fouls for them and 8 for us. Didn't feel like that watching it.

MT03ALG wrote: ↑

Tue Apr 08, 2025 10:35 pm

Average performance from the man from Otley (I think)

Im pretty sure he’s from Ossett not Otley but it’s still West Yorkshire. I have a feeing he’s more of a Huddersfield fan, we don’t seem to have ever had much from his or his brother.

If you also add last night’s draw to their combines statistics, they come out as:

Total games - 23

Burnley Wins - 10

Draws - 6

Burnley Losses - 7

The statistics don’t read too badly, when you consider there are several Premier League games in there as well

A 15
B 13
C 17
D 17

Jeez - we've had (and seen) a LOT worse this season, quite frankly

Thought he was good, first half. Only missed the foul on Pires? In our LB position that led to a corner and 5mins where we couldn’t get out.
Second half he was poor. Shouldn’t have missed the pen for Flemming being pulled back and if he did his lino should have given it. To many FKs for 50/50 challenges.

From TV thought he had a very good game
It is a man’s game and Derby were no more physical than Burnley

Pxxx poor .blatant penalty for the foul on Zian not given and ignored 90% of fouls by Derby

aggi wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 09, 2025 8:57 am

Everywhere has that the opposite way round. 14 fouls for them and 8 for us. Didn't feel like that watching it.

Yes my mistake thanks for that. Misread the stat and hard to get an accurate feel from low down in the away end.

Maybe Madley wasn’t quite as inconsistent as I had thought from watching it live?

KlyBfc wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 09, 2025 9:45 am

Im pretty sure he’s from Ossett not Otley but it’s still West Yorkshire. I have a feeing he’s more of a Huddersfield fan, we don’t seem to have ever had much from his or his brother.

He is from Ossett

DAVETHEVICAR wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 09, 2025 11:48 am

From TV thought he had a very good game
It is a man’s game and Derby were no more physical than Burnley

Which is a very good reason why John doesn't permit those watching on TV to vote.

CrosspoolClarets wrote: ↑

Tue Apr 08, 2025 10:51 pm

A - 10
B - 5
C - 12
D - 15

Played into their hands. Gave 14 fouls against us and 8 against them despite their physicality.

The fouls are the other way aren't they with 14 against them and eight against us?

ClaretTony wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 09, 2025 5:22 pm

The fouls are the other way aren't they with 14 against them and eight against us?

Yes, I’d already thanked aggi above for pointing that out.

The downside of letting those with a bad view on the ground to vote

CrosspoolClarets wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 09, 2025 12:38 pm

Yes my mistake thanks for that. Misread the stat and hard to get an accurate feel from low down in the away end.

Maybe Madley wasn’t quite as inconsistent as I had thought from watching it live?

I was surprised as well when I saw the stat. Felt like he'd not given us many free kicks and given them at least as many if not more.