West Brom v Burnley - Player Ratings

[Robbie_painter]

Bumba having a hissy fit about player ratings after all the bonk he posted about Trafford last season is hilarious.

[ksrclaret]

Bumba having a hissy fit about player ratings after all the bonk he posted about Trafford last season is hilarious.

The hypocrites always make the most noise on here

[Row x]

The hypocrites always make the most noise on here

And those with short memories

[Burnley1989]

Tbf, I wouldn't have scored anyone below a 5, possibly Koleosho, but I'd not argue a 5.

[bumba]

I'm sorry Bumba but can you honestly speak on this .
The lack of self awareness is unbelievable ( actually it's not)
With the agenda you had with Trafford last season.

There's too much main character syndrome on show on this message board.

Here's you scoring Trafford a 4 against West Ham last season. He wasn't outstanding but he was far from poor that day.

First of all thank you for proving how sad your life is that you have time to search my posts back to 2023
But yes I rated him poor, not abysmal.

It wasn't an agenda against Trafford he was poor last season. Can you prove me wrong on that?

[bumba]

Embarrassing
You really are the worst type of football supporter.
Stupid and blinkered is not a good combo.

Neither is a 'supporter' who comments on a game he didn't watch

[bumba]

Bumba having a hissy fit about player ratings after all the bonk he posted about Trafford last season is hilarious.

You mean about one of the poorest goalkeepers the premier league has ever seen?

[Robbie_painter]

You mean about one of the poorest goalkeepers the premier league has ever seen?

And he’s off hahahha

[Raconteur]

First of all thank you for proving how sad your life is that you have time to search my posts back to 2023
But yes I rated him poor, not abysmal.

It wasn't an agenda against Trafford he was poor last season. Can you prove me wrong on that?

Oh you have got me, my life is well sad
Again, a lack of self awareness.
It literally took less than 5 minutes to find that player rating thread.

Being poor over the season does not mean he was poor in every individual game.He wasn't poor against West Ham. So yes it was an agenda.

Why is it not dropping in that someone scoring Koleosho a 3 is the same as you with Trafford.

It's an opinion. Do you think your opinions hold more value than everyone else's.

[ecc]

Trafford 6: Had nothing to do despite West Brom mounting several attacks.
Roberts 7: He really is unpredictable. He drove me crazy on Sunday with his constant mispassing. Last night, he showed he can defend and link up. Difficult to work him out.
Egan-Riley 8: We need to see how it works out in the long term but this lad is THE success story of the season thus far. So little experience and yet he's stepped up a level in just a few weeks. Don Goodman named him MOM on Sky and he was right.
Estève 8: As the commentator said last night, Maxime never looks under pressure. Egan-Riley's progress is due to him to a considerable extent.
Pires 6: Struggled with Fellows in the first-half but he's not the first FB to do so. Got forward well and was unlucky with his shot hitting the post.
Cullen 7: Thought he played well. Silly booking which could have proved costly. He's far more involved than Brownhill and fortunately so.
Brownhill 4: I spent periods of the game focusing on him. I might well be missing what he's actually doing but I'd be interested to see how many times he actually touched the ball.
Anthony 6: Scored a valid goal. Don't think he could be faulted for his tracking back.
Sarmiento 6: I think we have to give credit to Palmer for coming out quickly.
Koleosho 5: Apart from one cross it's still not working. Time to bench him IMHO.
Flemming 5: Far too many fouls.


Much better than the Millwall horror show. Millwall cannot be criticised for the way they play - hassling, tenacious, trenchwar football - but West Brom have more gifted players and I expect them to be in the Top Six.

We didn't go to defend but we did it well when we needed to.
We looked more threatening and should have had a goal counted.
The forward four worked reasonably well.
It's clear SP and his staff are trying their best to get it right up top. I think we're getting closer.

[bumba]

Oh you have got me, my life is well sad
Again, a lack of self awareness.
It literally took less than 5 minutes to find that player rating thread.

Being poor over the season does not mean he was poor in every individual game.He wasn't poor against West Ham. So yes it was an agenda.

Why is it not dropping in that someone scoring Koleosho a 3 is the same as you with Trafford.

It's an opinion. Do you think your opinions hold more value than everyone else's.

More value? No.
More honesty? Yes.

So you are admitting you've an agenda against Koleosho?

[Newcastleclaret93]

More value? No.
More honesty? Yes.

So you are admitting you've an agenda against Koleosho?

I don’t mind either way your opinion on the matter, but I’m really struggling to see what he did that deserves more than a 3 in your opinion?

I thought he was poor in defence, often leaving Pires isolated 1v1.

Then in attack he just offered absolutely nothing and regularly lost the ball in promising positions.

I just can’t see how under any metric he can score higher. If he had been strong defensively and poor going forward I could understand it, but he just wasn’t.

[ClaretTony]

You mean about one of the poorest goalkeepers the premier league has ever seen?

On that you cannot be serious.

[Raconteur]

More value? No.
More honesty? Yes.

So you are admitting you've an agenda against Koleosho?

I haven't announced my thoughts on Koleoshos performances, so how could i have an agenda against him.

[Casper2]

this is better than a nil nil draw

[Burnley1989]

There's a few posters that have made me feel that way recently

[ClaretTony]

bumba and Big Vinny K now serving 24 hour suspensions. If either continue with this they will be removed for much longer.