Switzerland Women

[Dazzler]

I can't see any mention of men's football in the article

Why would they have been

[TheFamilyCat]

What's bizarre? I posted a link where the word Elite was used for a 20-year-old Woman keeper to point out why some folk may
see it as comparing it to Men's football.

Again, I'll go back to my original reply, if "some people" interpret that as comparing ti men's sport, the problem is with them.

[aggi]

What's bizarre? I posted a link where the word Elite was used for a 20-year-old Woman keeper to point out why some folk may
see it as comparing it to Men's football.

With this usage of elite I found this article really confusing
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cwyd99pkegpo

[Dazzler]

Again, I'll go back to my original reply, if "some people" interpret that as comparing ti men's sport, the problem is with them.

Would their problem be that they have different views & opinions from yours?

[TheFamilyCat]

Why would they have been

No reason but as you are using it as your evidence thst women’s football is compared as being equal to men's i thought it was relevant.

[TheFamilyCat]

Would their problem be that they have different views & opinions from yours?

No, their problem is their inability to read and understand what's written, as you have proved.

[Dazzler]

No reason but as you are using it as your evidence thst women’s football is compared as being equal to men's i thought it was relevant.

Fffs, where have I written that the media compares women's football to men's? I gave an example as to why some folk may see it that way.

[TheFamilyCat]

Fffs, where have I written that the media compares women's football to men's? I gave an example as to why some folk may see it that way.

Screenshot_20250627_190818_Samsung Internet.jpg (126.09 KiB) Viewed 651 times

You posted a link in reply to a question on exactly thst.

[Dazzler]

Screenshot_20250627_190818_Samsung Internet.jpg

You posted a link in reply to a question on exactly thst.

Another Ffs, you are seeing things that are not there. I gave an example of why some folk might see it that way.

If I thought the media compared women's football to the standard of men's football' I would say so.

What I will say, however, I think they hype it up a bit too much.

[wilks_bfc]

Another Ffs, you are seeing things that are not there. I gave an example of why some folk might see it that way.

If I thought the media compared women's football to the standard of men's football' I would say so.

What I will say, however, I think they hype it up a bit too much.

Understand completely the point you are trying to make. Of course there are “elite women footballers”, but they are elite compared to other women footballers.

I’ve had some involvement in girls football and the progress in that side of the game has been phenomenal, especially at the younger ages, and I’m all for the women’s game being pushed, however IMO the media are hyping up the women’s game to the detriment of the women’s game.

BBC & SSN having breaking news of “Aston Villa singing Barca defender” coming up, when it turns out to be the women’s team is what gets some people worked up. Them include news from the women’s game within segments for the men’s game is what makes people think they are “equal”

[boatshed bill]

I’ve had some involvement in girls football and the progress in that side of the game has been phenomenal, especially at the younger ages, and I’m all for the women’s game being pushed, however IMO the media are hyping up the women’s game to the detriment of the women’s game.

This is the point, mixing the women's game's headlines and results can be really irritating.

[AlargeClaret]

That's just more bullshit though, isn't it? Can you provide any links to anywhere in the media anyone has claimed that women's football is of equal standard to men's?

It’s not about it being equal in the literal sense , it’s just how the media promote /discus women’s football as if it’s pretty much on equal terms like headlines for eg . Admittedly it’s partly agenda rather than audience driven .
Take swimming , athletics or cycling where it’s simply physiology holding them back ,yet the women in these sports get scant publicity and little money unless an Olympics year etc .

[NewClaret]

https://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/64319728

That article was from two and a half years ago.

It’s also a decision rather than a debate, but either way it’s not very current!

[Dazzler]

Understand completely the point you are trying to make. Of course there are “elite women footballers”, but they are elite compared to other women footballers.

l

The link I posted of goalkeeper Safia Middleton Patel

.. life as an autistic elite footballer...............The 20-year-old keeper.................hugely promising

The article fails to inform that she has yet to make her debut for Man u and she's played only 10 games out on loan.

Is she Elite or promising?

[timshorts]

l

The link I posted of goalkeeper Safia Middleton Patel

.. life as an autistic elite footballer...............The 20-year-old keeper.................hugely promising

The article fails to inform that she has yet to make her debut for Man u and she's played only 10 games out on loan.

Is she Elite or promising?

Well, she's at the world cup.....

[ecc]

Not unlike few yrs ago the all conquering US women’s team were beat 5-2 by an u15 Dallas ( I think ) academy team .
It’s a bit harsh to compare the 2 games , though it’s the media that are ramming the women’s game “ being equal “ down our throats .Unfortunately their core product is just very poor as a spectacle , it’s not their fault , it’s just what it is .

It's true the media coverage is immense. But then one doesn't have to read it.

[Dazzler]

That article was from two and a half years ago.

It’s also a decision rather than a debate, but either way it’s not very current!

To come to that decision, it must have gone beyond a debate & with it not being very current proves it's happening & likely to spread throughout the womens game.

So,what was your point in replying?

[Burnley1989]

My girls play sport, one has played football for 4 seasons and i love watching it.
Is the football anywhere near as good as my mates sons sides, absolutely not, but its still entertaining.
As others have said, its totally different but its their game as well, let them enjoy it and stop telling them theyre crap because boys/men are better.