Dyche's best signing

[Steve1956]

For me has to be Defour,just a pity he couldnt keep fit!

[Bin Ont Turf]

Too many to pick just one.

The three Amigos in his first summer transfer window take some beating, but then you have Barton and Defour. who were influential in their time.

Barnes for his longevity and goals, Keane for the Rolls Royce and bringing us the most money.

And you could choose a number of them from the current team.

[Wuggawumphwumph]

David Jones

[DCWat]

Too many to pick just one.

The three Amigos in his first summer transfer window take some beating, but then you have Barton and Defour. who were influential in their time.

Barnes for his longevity and goals, Keane for the Rolls Royce and bringing us the most money.

And you could choose a number of them from the current team.

I’d love to pick Defour but I don’t think we got the longevity for him to warrant being classed as Dyche’s best signing.

If it was the best player that Dyche had signed, it’d probably not be far off a one horse race.

It’s tough to call between four standouts for me…. Tarkowski, Heaton, Pope and Keane. Not only taking into account contribution, but also the cost of said players.

Fingers crossed we’ll be saying the same about Collins in a year or two!!

[Bin Ont Turf]

I’d love to pick Defour but I don’t think we got the longevity for him to warrant being classed as Dyche’s best signing.

If it was the best player that Dyche had signed, it’d probably not be far off a one horse race.

It’s tough to call between four standouts for me…. Tarkowski, Heaton, Pope and Keane. Not only taking into account contribution, but also the cost of said players.

Fingers crossed we’ll be saying the same about Collins in a year or two!!

Yes, we probably do need an exact definition of 'best'.

[Steve-Harpers-perm]

As above Heaton, Jones and Arfield were key to where it all began.

Barton and Gray to help us get straight back up as well.

[Longsider]

Himself

[ClaretTony]

David Jones

Too many didn't realise just how big an influence he was

[superdimitri]

Jones really showed how much McCann had declined. He bought the best out of Dean Marney.

[Suratclaret]

Not easy to choose but...
Heaton, Arfield, Ward and Jones.

[Shaggy]

The best in terms ability was head and shoulders Defour.

Thought I’d see George Boyd get a mention he was immense for us under Dyche him and Scotty Arfield.

[Lord_Bob]

My original thought was Heaton - relegated championship goalie - let's in 80. Dyche sees what he really is - great goalie - better person. Turns into an England international, club captain. Free transfer.

But then, thinking about it, the Joey Barton signing was a stroke of f***king genius. Another free and exactly what we needed to get back in the Prem. No-one else would touch him, but Dyche saw through it and what he could bring to the team. Got us back to the Prem - genius.

[leelad]

Tom Heaton for me, but Joey Barton is a very close 2nd.

[Culmclaret]

A bit controversially …Gray. Did exactly the job we wanted and we made a tidy profit

[TheFamilyCat]

no howe

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wck6YaZytmM

[Tribesmen]

Joey was the first name to jump out at me and will have to think about the other two

[JTClaret]

Initial thought is Heaton... but there's a few.
- Pope
- Lowton
- Keane
- Tarks
- Barton
- Arfield
- Westwood
- Gray (controversial maybe, but what do you want from a signing? Promotion, Profit and the fact we never missed Ings)
- Wood
- Barnes

[whiffa]

My three votes were for:

- Tom Heaton
- Joey Barton
- James Tarkowski

But you could easily argue for every single one of them, great shortlist.