Salford v Burnley - Player Ratings

[ClaretTony]

Just interested to understand whether you went to the game ?
I didn’t so haven’t scored.
On the extended highlights Zaroury made all 4 goals and also nearly scored with the keeper making a very good save. From the BBC live text service and sky sports reporting it sounded like Zaroury was at the heart of pretty much everything we did.

How can you score him the same score as 2 players who only played 30 minutes of the game ?

Zaroury outstanding last night, absolutely no doubt about that. Topped only by Berge in my view.

[IanMcL]

Just interested to understand whether you went to the game ?
I didn’t so haven’t scored.
On the extended highlights Zaroury made all 4 goals and also nearly scored with the keeper making a very good save. From the BBC live text service and sky sports reporting it sounded like Zaroury was at the heart of pretty much everything we did.

How can you score him the same score as 2 players who only played 30 minutes of the game ?

Yes. Was there. He did do some good stuff. Not always. I wouldn't argue for a 7 but plumped for 6, as I thought that the whole team made the game easy against a poor team. Hence why I scored low. Not the more often high scores of the Championship.
I thought Berge was the better player but he only got 7 on the night.

[KlyBfc]

Muric 6
Vintinho 5
OShea 7
Cork 7
Del 6
Berge 8
Zaroury 8
Benson 6
Laursen 8
Jay 5
Odobert 7

Tresor 6
Messengo 7
Roberts 6

[Big Vinny K]

Yes. Was there. He did do some good stuff. Not always. I wouldn't argue for a 7 but plumped for 6, as I thought that the whole team made the game easy against a poor team. Hence why I scored low. Not the more often high scores of the Championship.
I thought Berge was the better player but he only got 7 on the night.

So how does a player who made 4 goals and played 96 minutes get the same score as 2 players who played 30 minutes and had zero assists ?
Messengo and Roberts must have been bloody brilliant !!

If you are taking into account the opposition being poor into your scores into the 6 you gave Zaroury then most of the rest of the players would surely be 3s and 4s.

[BleedingClaret]

I’d suggest that when he’s played the equivalent of a game and half across 3 substitute appearances, No.

I know, give the lad a chance his digestion is just getting used to pie peas & gravy & half a mild for dinner at lunch time
His clogs are killing him and he's allergic to his new whippet

[SalouClaret]

Yes. Was there. He did do some good stuff. Not always. I wouldn't argue for a 7 but plumped for 6, as I thought that the whole team made the game easy against a poor team. Hence why I scored low. Not the more often high scores of the Championship.
I thought Berge was the better player but he only got 7 on the night.

You've had a mare.

How does Zaroury get the same rating as someone who played for 25 minutes and did nothing? surely Massengo should get a 3, Salford are a shite team right?

[SalouClaret]

So how does a player who made 4 goals and played 96 minutes get the same score as 2 players who played 30 minutes and had zero assists ?
Messengo and Roberts must have been bloody brilliant !!

If you are taking into account the opposition being poor into your scores into the 6 you gave Zaroury then most of the rest of the players would surely be 3s and 4s.

Beat me to it.

[fidelcastro]

So how does a player who made 4 goals and played 96 minutes get the same score as 2 players who played 30 minutes and had zero assists ?
Messengo and Roberts must have been bloody brilliant !!

If you are taking into account the opposition being poor into your scores into the 6 you gave Zaroury then most of the rest of the players would surely be 3s and 4s.

You're wasting your breath. He hasn't got a clue!

[Big Vinny K]

You're wasting your breath. He hasn't got a clue!

I’d be just saying it was a keyboard error and i meant to press 9 !!

Players ratings are all about opinions I know but this is akin to saying Haaland scored 5 goals against Fulchester Rovers but he did very little else !!

[fidelcastro]

I’d be just saying it was a keyboard error and i meant to press 9 !!

Players ratings are all about opinions I know but this is akin to saying Haaland scored 5 goals against Fulchester Rovers but he did very little else !!

I wouldn't worry. This is someone who blasts goalkeepers for not saving shots that go wide!

Apparently people vote for him too. Incredible.

[IanMcL]

I award you 3 Fidel!

[fidelcastro]

I award you 3 Fidel!

More than I was expecting.

Cheers.

[IanMcL]

More than I was expecting.

Cheers.

you did your best.

Thing to consider is the view you get, stuck in a corner, at the far end, for one half. You can't catch everything.

Anaas probably was a good 7 on reflection, however, I did my scores on the way back, in the early hours. Just thought the whole team controlled everything against a very poor side. They were missing some players and are not exactly cutting it in their league. We have lots of talent.