Post
by CrosspoolClarets » Sat Mar 01, 2025 10:16 pm
Hladky 4 - from his seat sat with us in the stands Traff could have got across to save the first. No howlers today unlike R3 & R4
Sonne 3 - really rank and looks a poor signing. A full international so one must assume it is the pace of English football. That one just before the first goal when he attacked, turned back, and then didn’t feed it in left footed to 3 onrushing teammates - scandalous. Probably moves faster when on his catwalk.
Pires 5 - battled, limited but did ok. I am guessing he was switched to the right because Sonne was being torn a new one every minute. Which was incredible and not something I have ever seen.
Worrall 5 - we have been blessed with half a dozen top class CB talents in the last decade, Joe is a good guy but this makes him look really, really limited. He did Ok though to a degree.
Esteve 5 - bullied and an area he needs to improve at for the Premier, whoever he plays for there
Shelvey 3 - looked so far off the pace he shouldn’t have been picked. That he was, in the engine room, despite obvious fitness limits, well, it is close to being a sackable offence because it sacked off the competition
Brownhill 5 - hustled but isn’t a physical player (none of those were allowed today but we lacked it desparately), he is an energetic one and that wasn’t enough next to Jonjo
Sarmiento 5 - an enigma. I see desire, battling, skill, but it is all sporadic. He is at a crucial choice in his career and I feel he will choose mediocrity.
Benson 5 - some good moments but a tricky one on that pitch
Koleosho 6 - probably our best of a bad bunch. Energy (as ever). Some quality. But too much straight line running which isn’t ideal if its a dead end.
Foster 5 - energy and some runs but never really threatened which is his issue
Flemming 6 - slight improvement
Barnes 6 - slight improvement
Laurent 5 - thought he would add grit but didn’t
Edwards 5 - match was gone and he couldn't have done much
Banel 4 - not sure he did anything at all
I put this on the draw thread minutes after we got PNE:
“If Parker plays a weakened side and loses to a local rival in our first ever cup meeting, many fans will call for him to go. If we somehow fail to go up anyway, many won’t forgive him. So I really, really hope he is clever here and does the right thing. Feels important.”
I was right then, sensed what was coming. That was an own goal. Wins feed wins and we chose to sack off the FA Cup with near certain defeat. No win on Tuesday or Saturday now feels likely. A bit like Olympiacos then Fulham. I’ll be glad if I call that wrong.
You just don’t do it. It alienates a large chunk of fans, 5000 of whom went and got badly let down. A game like this on that cabbage patch needed physicality - Laurent, Hannibal and Flemming in particular. Parker knows this. So he sacked it off.
Sack is probably the right word. If promotion, I’ll agree the pragmatism and tactical negativity worked. If we stay down……..he would then be not good enough for Burnley and would have to go before a second attempt. We are not Fulham or Bournemouth. We have won major trophies, the first side Parker has managed who has. We don’t expect to try and win these competitions. We demand it.