Brownhill

[fidelcastro]

Surely if he goes to Celtic it will be on a free transfer and we will get no fee
He is a free agent and can negotiate a move

We got a fee for Jay, so what's the difference?

[beddie]

It feels like Celtic to me. I hope I’m wrong I think he offers a lot more to the team than some people see.

[AlargeClaret]

Been a great servant but now he’s gone ( probably why Shelvey brought in ?) we need to kick on . With Benson coming back , and hopefully a new centre forward incoming we should have just enough to get over the line .

[The Shire Claret]

Then you surely agree with me then?

He wouldn't have made any difference today.

No I think it showed how much we miss him

[ElectroClaret]

Injured (Parker after match comments)

[fidelcastro]

No I think it showed how much we miss him

Yeah right.

[The Shire Claret]

Yeah right.

It’s perfectly fine for 2 people to disagree

[Row x]

Been a great servant but now he’s gone ( probably why Shelvey brought in ?) we need to kick on . With Benson coming back , and hopefully a new centre forward incoming we should have just enough to get over the line .

He's not gone
Benson not the answer
Don't think a centre forward is coming in ( hope I'm wrong)

[boatshed bill]

I think he drops a bit of a hint that he might be leaving in his most recent interview.
been a good servant, best of luck to him.

[AlargeClaret]

He's not gone
Benson not the answer
Don't think a centre forward is coming in ( hope I'm wrong)

Perhaps he hasn’t yet , but it’s highly unlikely he’s injured . He’s either holding the club to ransom for a contract extension and club have either said no way or are negotiating with him , most likely why his agent has put the “ Celtic move” out there .Benson could be just what’s needed at this level , though he’s so fragile he may break down again .

[Woodleyclaret]

Surely not going in January and wasting his talent with Celtic ? that would be a serious error for us and Josh

[Pearcey]

The Scottish league is absolute guff but it would be a decent move for him. He’s a top championship player but is lower end in the prem. I do hope he stays though!

[Pickles]

He walks into most if not all other Championship sides. And as seen as we're a Championship side, it'd be a loss to lose him. Shelvey isn't a like for like replacement and there are questions about his fitness and his long term involvement.

Brownhill has been very good during a very successful period for Burnley.

If he is to leave, he needs replacing.

[colne-claret]

Surely not going in January and wasting his talent with Celtic ? that would be a serious error for us and Josh

Probs his best chance of winning titles and playing European football.

[bumba]

He walks into most if not all other Championship sides. And as seen as we're a Championship side, it'd be a loss to lose him. Shelvey isn't a like for like replacement and there are questions about his fitness and his long term involvement.

Brownhill has been very good during a very successful period for Burnley.

If he is to leave, he needs replacing.

He doesn't get in the Leeds or Sunderland team

[Pickles]

He doesn't get in the Leeds or Sunderland team

"most if not all"

[Clive 1960]

If Brownhill is leaving in this window it shows how ambitious our club is as he's captain and we are 3rd in the league , for me let him go for free in the summer if he wants to go, rather have him in the team which gives us a chance of promotion.

[alboclaret]

If he is going, I wouldn't under estimate the impact that has on the squad. He's obviously very popular among the squad and captain leaving halfway through chasing promotion could be a bit disappointing for some other members.

[wilks_bfc]

I think he drops a bit of a hint that he might be leaving in his most recent interview.
been a good servant, best of luck to him.

Which interview?

[Row x]

Perhaps he hasn’t yet , but it’s highly unlikely he’s injured . He’s either holding the club to ransom for a contract extension and club have either said no way or are negotiating with him , most likely why his agent has put the “ Celtic move” out there .Benson could be just what’s needed at this level , though he’s so fragile he may break down again .

It's been mentioned by one commentator, for an American broadcast, it's not mentioned anywhere else, so if, as you suggest his agent is putting it out there, he's not doing a very good job!!!

[bumba]

"most if not all"

Point being?? You put 'if not all' so I was making it clear 'not all'

[AlargeClaret]

It's been mentioned by one commentator, for an American broadcast, it's not mentioned anywhere else, so if, as you suggest his agent is putting it out there, he's not doing a very good job!!!

It was all over the football online sites going back to the 30th I think , then got picked up by trash like Lancs online etc , very early yesterday . While it’s an odd one , you can see why players his age head up to Glasgow , champs league /europa , gives a glow to their later careers . Think of Scotty Arfield cracking move for him . Id like him to stay but he’ll want a 2 yr contract surely ?

[boatshed bill]

Which interview?

Clarets+, pre-match vs Portsmouth.
But I've just had a quick look and couldn't find it.

[boatshed bill]

Which interview?

Found it on Youtube, just over 3 minutes in.